This week I enjoyed the presentation from our quest speaker,
Professor Jackson, who did an excellent job of explaining various aspects of
the brain that relate to neuroscience and cognition. It was the first time that
learning about parts of the brain was not boring, but rather quite interesting.
He explained various parts of the brain and their functions as relating to
various defects in the physiology of the brain.
What intrigued me most, and inspired me to write this,
was the last section about “Myth Busting the Brain.” How mortifying! I was one who believed in all of them, so
naturally I was beside myself. I thought,
how was I now going to justify those beliefs to myself now? The left brain/
right brain theory was the first to baffle my mind. When he explained where the
myth began, I was able to readily understand that it is the whole brain that is
used and that either side may be more activated at various times.
Another myth was one regarding how “puzzles boost brains.” An example of such being the website Luminosity,
as it claims to help you “reclaim your brain.” This also took me by surprise. I
recently considered investing in the website and actually participated in one
of their trials. The program’s intention was to have us believe that one’s
cognitive skills would be greatly improved by using their website and playing their
mind games. No doubt, as explained by Professor Jackson, the action of practicing
these puzzles is the means for doing better at them as time progresses – but does
not have an actual effect on your cognitive function or the “strength” of your brain.
A similar program that I indulged in with my daughter
during my pregnancy and after she was born and preached to other parents about
is the Baby Einstein series of tapes and DVDs. They alleged their ability to
greatly improve children’s cognitive development. It’s even been stated that by
playing Mozart or any classical music to developing fetuses that they would get
a head start on better cognitive skills.
The idea that listening to classical music can increase your brainpower
has become so popular that it's been dubbed "the Mozart effect."
I was one of those parents who actually fell for this and took part in it. How
silly do I feel now? This particular myth started in the 1930’s when an ear,
nose, and throat specialist had suggested that people with auditory disorders
could have improved speech by listening to Mozart. Then in 1990, a study had
been done regarding IQ tests in which it was suggested that listening to Mozart
prior to taking the test resulted in higher test scores. Hence, “the Mozart
effect” was born. (http://science.howstuffworks.com/life/inside-the-mind/human-brain/10-brain-myths.htm#page=2)
The world of commercialism has and continues to apparently
dupe a large majority of people into believing such myths to sell products. I
recently came across an article entitled, “Age-Proof Your Brain” in Healthy
Living Magazine. This article goes on to state, “So-called senior moments can
be unsettling and frustrating, but we tend to accept them as a non-negotiable
result of aging. In fact, researchers now believe that we don’t have to just
sit back and let our gray matter fizzle over time.” Gray matter was something
that Professor Jackson had also discussed with us in his presentation, so I
thought this was quite interesting to now be reading this article. The article
further claims, “New imaging technologies are revealing that the brain is far
more elastic than we believe.” It suggests that through the use of “Brain
Trainers” and Mind Games such as Sudoku, Rubik’s Cubes, and Crossword Puzzles,
the brain is more likely to have neuroplacticity, according to researchers, and
that will make the brain more resistant to disease because these games work
areas of the brain responsible for memory in the hippocampus and for language
in the left temporal lobe. This information was given by a Dr. Hall who also
says, “They [the games] also encourage different parts of the brain to work
together.”
So, what are we all supposed to believe after a pitch
like that? As Professor Jackson explained, those behind such myths claim as
fact that they are “built on proven neuroscience,” yet it now makes more sense
to me that it is more likely a result of practicing these so called mind games
over and over again (Practice Effects) as stated previously. And also according
to Professor Jackson, we all know that things are showed and demonstrated, not proven,
and it’s about “science not magic.”
No comments:
Post a Comment